By ShowMeStepByStepPublished
Based on a video by Pattymac Makes.
The microwave makes leftover pizza soggy. The oven works but takes 15 minutes once you count preheat time. The air fryer hits the sweet spot: 5 minutes, no preheat, crust as crispy as the day you ordered it. For one or two slices, it's the best tool in the kitchen.
The technique is simple: 380°F for 5 minutes. The temperature is hot enough to crisp the crust quickly, cool enough that the cheese doesn't burn before the bottom is done. Most air fryers don't even need preheating - they hit cooking temperature in under a minute and start working.
The perforated basket is what makes this beat the oven. Hot air circulates underneath the crust, so the bottom crisps without you having to flip the slice. Pull it out hot, eat immediately. Reheated pizza in the air fryer is best within a minute of coming out; let it sit and the steam softens the crust again.
Plug in your air fryer and let it sit for a moment to confirm it boots up. Most air fryers don't need a preheat for reheating - they hit cooking temperature in under a minute.
This is part of why they beat the oven for one-slice pizza reheats. No 10-minute preheat cycle for a 5-minute job.
Pull the basket out of the air fryer. Most air fryers have a removable basket with a perforated bottom that lifts the food off the floor of the unit so air can circulate underneath.
The perforations are how the bottom of the crust gets crispy without needing to flip the pizza. This is the main thing the air fryer does that the oven doesn't.
Place the pizza slice flat in the basket, crust down. One slice fits comfortably in most baskets; two slices works for larger air fryers if you don't overlap them.
Don't oil or grease the basket - the pizza already has enough fat. Slide the basket back into the air fryer.
Set the temperature to 380°F. This is the sweet spot - hot enough to crisp the crust quickly, cool enough that the cheese doesn't burn before the bottom is done.
Some air fryers have a dedicated reheat preset; manual 380°F is more reliable across brands. If your air fryer only goes by 25-degree increments, 375°F or 400°F both work fine.
Set the timer for 5 minutes and press start.
Five minutes works for a standard slice from cold or fridge temperature. For thicker deep-dish or stuffed crust, bump it to 6 or 7 minutes. For a thin-crust slice that's already at room temperature, 3 to 4 minutes is enough.
Tip
If the pizza is still partially frozen, add 2-3 minutes to the time. Don't try to reheat from frozen at a higher temperature - the outside burns before the middle thaws.
When the timer goes off, the air fryer turns off automatically. Pull the basket out carefully - the metal handle stays cool but the food and basket interior are very hot.
The crust should be crisp and golden. The cheese should be melted and slightly bubbly. If the cheese isn't quite there, return it for another minute.
Slide the pizza out onto a plate with a spatula. Let it rest for 30 seconds - the cheese will be molten and you don't want to burn the roof of your mouth.
Eat immediately. Reheated pizza in the air fryer is best within a minute of coming out; it loses crispness as it sits because the steam from the cheese softens the crust again.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page may be affiliate links - clicking them and buying doesn't change your price, but helps support ShowMeStepByStep.
